How to Stimulate Blog Growth When You Start to Stagnate

My site is growing and shrinking at the same time. Facebook likes has increased from a dozen to almost 150 in the last month, there are legitimate fans posting comments and lots of user interaction with the content — even sharing it (5–10 average FB shares per post, plus Stumble & Twitter). Yet, somehow, my daily visitors is dropping. I suspect it has something to do with not having a steady influx of new eyeballs on the content (I was lucky to write a few guest posts for fair sized sites early on), but I can only approach so many people to do guest posts every month, and I can only spend so much time finding related sites to interact with/reach out to. I know that growth takes time, but I do not like seeing any stat trend downward. Given that my content/site seems “proven” to retain readers, how would you recommend I proceed with my growth?

- Zane Claes, Life By Experimentation

Hey Zane!

This honestly doesn’t sound like something I’d worry about too much. In my experience, there just tend to be down months. I’d only worry if this continues for a long period of time (say 3 to 6 months). However, to curb the trend I have a few suggestions:

  • Though you have a limited amount of time for them, more guest posts will definitely help you reach a new audience. You might want to focus just on the biggest and the best, maybe trying to write another post for sites you’ve already written for.
  • Form a mastermind group with likeminded, similarly-sized bloggers. The purpose will be to promote each others stuff and to share growth advice. It’s definitely easier to grow a blog if other people are involved.
  • Connect with the influencers in your niche. Talk to them and be as helpful as possible. You might gain a mentor or be given opportunities you might not otherwise be given. At the very least, something as simple as an influencer tweeting out your post could put thousands of new eyeballs in front of your site.
  • Start a newsletter with a freebie. If monetization is your goal, collecting email addresses will make things easier in the future anyway. Create a freebie that is so remarkable it markets itself.

Those are just a few things you can do. If you want to know my honest opinion, you are in the best possible position right now. Of course you don’t want your blog to stagnate, but you seem to have a devoted following. Devoted followings trust you, love you, read everything you write. They are true fans and true fans are the ones who trust you enough to spend money on you and to spread your message.

You might not have attracted the number of people you want to, but you have attracted a very concentrated group of the RIGHT people. Yesterday, I received an influx of visitors from Hacker News. About 5500 compared to my average 150 to 250 daily visitors. These people visited one page on average and stayed for about 11 seconds. They weren’t very highly engaged.

I have a hierarchy of what I want visitors to do when they get to this site:

  1. Subscribe to the email list
  2. Contact me via the contact form
  3. Like the page on Facebook
  4. Follow me on Twitter
  5. Share articles
  6. Subscribe via RSS

Of these, only a few of that 5500 did either of the top two, none did 3 or 4. Those are the most important actions my visitors can take. I got a higher number of Facebook and Twitter shares than usual and I doubled my RSS readers, but that doesn’t mean much to me.

The point is, large audiences don’t necessarily mean a better blog, so losing daily visitors isn’t a huge issue as long as the ones you have are engaged and dedicated. You’re in a great position and you’re only going to grow from here, even if it does turn out to be a slow process (which I doubt it will be.)

Similar Posts:

    None Found



Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
tomdiggity 5 pts

Nice post JD, as usual.

Look, we are all in the same boat and it is about curating an audience. The problem is the "audience" concept is kinda dead: We have individuals to engage with, and the trick is finding the niche that works for you. It happens over time.Did you know that Angry Birds was a complete flop for the first 3 months? A complete disaster. There are things at which we succeed, and there are things from which we learn. Talk to people that have 10k, or even 100k + followers. Most of them will tell you that for the first 6 months it seemed like no one was listening and the only comments they got on their site was spam.

Sometimes things have unexpected consequences. (I swear this is to illustrate a point, not promotion...) I had a post go live yesterday about Twitter Archetypes:

http://www.pistachiomedia.org/social-media/twitter/twitter-archetypes/

Immediately after reading I lost a substantial amount of twitter followers. Using Postrank, Google Analytics and Who Unfollowed me I really must have some upset some folks. 12 hours later I have received some messages they liked it. Whatever...The point is that if you find your voice, others will find you.

Sorry for rambling...

jdbentley 14 pts

tomdiggity I think the best advice I've heard is to separate, in your mind, audience from niche. Your audience is a certain kind of person and your niche is how try to appeal to that certain kind of person. I actually just finished a video about this for my upcoming free blogging course.

Also, what you're saying brought to mind Seth Godin's The Dip and Malcolm Gladwell's Tipping Point. Things always seem to be at their lowest point right before that event (whatever it is) that makes you explode. It's really all about working hard and being consistent.

And regarding your loss of readers, I'm glad you don't seem to care about it. It's better to offend people with your honest opinions, since the people who agree will be turned into true fans. Try to please everyone and you please no one, as they say.

By the way, it takes a real man to make an infographic out of HTML. You're like "The Oatmeal" for internet marketing nerds. I love it!

tomdiggity 5 pts

jdbentley Thanks man, that means a lot. For your readers that don't know, it was your suggestion I went with Headway and it a shout out to the J Shortcodes plugin for WP that lets me do those crazy columns.

Big fan of Godin & Gladwell.

Let me know when you launch your Blogging course, I'll help spread the word.

mikerobertsbgh 5 pts

really solid advice here. I especially like the hierarchy of what you want each visitor to your site to do.

jdbentley 14 pts

mikerobertsbgh Most bloggers don't bother figuring out what they want their readers to do. They leave it to chance. The hierarchy is a good thing to keep in mind when you make decisions about your design or think about adding a new feature to the blog. Your design HAS TO support your goals.

annedreshfield 228 pts

Great tips, J.D. I have a very small blog but I'm slowly starting to grow my audience -- will definitely keep this blog post in mind!

jdbentley 14 pts

annedreshfield Awesome! Make sure to let me know how it goes. I really like your blog's design. It has a literary feel to it, like I was reading the New Yorker or something. It was really content-centric. Looks like you've got a great start on that!

annedreshfield 228 pts

jdbentley Thanks, that means a lot. :)

Zane the Experimenter 5 pts

Thanks for this great response, J. D.!

Your statistics from Hacker News was very enlightening. My general assumption is that we need the quantity of eyeballs in order to translate into readers, but I do tend to forget that one recommendation from a reader to his friend can be more powerful than 100 random visitors.

jdbentley 14 pts

Zane the Experimenter Yeah, I'd take 2 referred readers over 2000 random readers any day. Quantity is a fun, but vain metric. I loved seeing 3000 unexpected views when I woke up, I loved watching it grow throughout the day, but it gave me little more than bragging rights. That's all viral content tends to offer. You're definitely on the right path, though. I love your blog's design!

Trackbacks

  1. […] being the case, viral audiences don’t do a lot. As I mentioned before, I have a particular hierarchy of action that I want readers to take. At the top of that list is […]